BBG Watch Commentary
UPDATE 10:00PM ET
It turns out that VOA English News posted a report at about 5PM ET somewhere on its website, in which it mentions U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul’s statement of condolences in connection with the terror attack in Volgograd. This report, however, does not have a prominent link on the VOA English homepage and does not appear in the VOA Europe News section. The report itself was posted late — many hours after Ambassador McFaul’s statement appeared online and was already reported by RT (Voice of Russia).
VOA English News is still not reporting anywhere on the State Department statement condemning the attack. A report on the bombing which is featured on the homepage as the lead news does not have any references to Ambassador McFaul’s statement and includes outdated information that ought to have been corrected hours ago.
Suicide Bomber Kills 16 in Russian Train Station, VOA News, posted late afternoon ET, Dec. 29.
In other words, this report with a reference to Ambassador McFaul’s statement cannot be found unless someone does a search of the entire website. This late-posted report does not mention the State Department statement to the press by spokeswoman Jen Psaki.
The report that can be seen on the homepage as of 9:20PM ET and also in the VOA Europe News section does not have any references to Ambassador McFaul’s statement or to the State Department statement. Anybody who goes to the VOA English site will see this outdated report and not the other one, which is also outdated.
Interestingly, in the VOA English website’s Europe News section, the Russia terror bombing report appears as number 5 news item after such reports as “F1 Racer Schumacher ‘Critical’ After Skiing Accident” and “French ‘Millionaire’s Tax’ Gets Constitutional Go-Ahead.”
VOA Director David Ensor and VOA Executive Editor Steve Redisch should know that their English website is certainly unique in this kind of news selection and lineup even when compared to such major European international media outlets as BBC and Deutsche Welle.
This report also includes disputed information about a female bomber, which Al Jazeera, BBC, DW, RT (Russia Today) and other international media have already corrected hours ago.
LEAD VOA NEWS REPORT ON ENGLISH HOMEPAGE AS OF 9:20PM ET
The report includes disputed information about a female suicide bomber and has no references to statements by Ambassador McFaul and the State Department.
Suicide Bomber Kills 16 at Russian Train Station — 9:20PM VOA Homepage Link
Jessica Golloher
December 29, 2013
MOSCOW — Russian officials say they believe a female suicide bomber caused an explosion that killed at least 16 people and wounded dozens Sunday at the entrance to a train station in Volgograd. The latest attack in southern Russia occurred about 650 kilometers northeast of Sochi, which will host the Winter Olympics in February.
Russia’s federal investigative committee says the bomber walked into a busy train station in Volgograd and detonated explosives just in front of metal detectors.
Vladimir Markin, who heads Russia’s Investigative Committee, said that this explosion was the equivalent of 10 kilograms of TNT.
He said there would have been many more victims if the so-called guarding system at the train station hadn’t worked. He pointed out that security did not allow the suicide bomber to get through the metal detector into the waiting hall where at the time there were lots of people because three trains were late.
This is the second recent deadly bombing in the city of around one million. In October, a female suicide bomber blew herself up at a bus stop, killing six others.
Volgograd is around 650 kilometers northeast of Sochi, the site for the upcoming Winter Olympics, a pet project of Russian President Vladimir Putin.
In an online video, Chechen militant leader Doku Umarov has called on rebels to use maximum force to prevent Mr. Putin from staging the Olympics. Putin has maintained that the games will be safe and that the Kremlin has taken every necessary precaution.
Sochi is situated near the volatile North Caucasus region, on Russia’s southern flank. The region has seen violence for more than a decade as rebels try to establish an Islamist state. There are near-daily attacks on police and officials in the region. Critics blame the violence there on the Kremlin’s crackdown on dissent.
Sunday’s train-station attack is believed to be the deadliest in three years. In 2011, 37 people were killed when Islamist insurgents bombed a Moscow airport.
On Friday, three people died in another attack some 270 kilometers east of Volgograd, in the city of Pyatigorsk.
This VOA report is on the VOA website, but as of 9:20PM ET there are no links to it on the homepage or in the Europe News section. It was posted inside the website late afternoon ET. This report, which also has not been updated in the last five hours (as of 10PM ET) also includes disputed information about a female bomber that other media such as BBC, RT, DW, and Al Jazeera have corrected many hours ago.
Suicide Bomber Kills 16 in Russian Train Station
December 29, 2013
Authorities in southern Russia say a female suicide bomber blew herself up at a train station in the southern city of Volgograd, killing at least 16 people and wounding dozens.
An investigative committee spokesman says the woman set off the bomb in front of the metal detectors at the station entrance early Sunday morning.
Television footage shows a big orange fireball just inside the station as smoke pours out of the windows.
No one has claimed responsibility for the attack. But authorities found what they say was the bomber’s severed head. They identify her as coming from Dagestan, a republic in the nearby volatile North Caucasus.
U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul extendedhis condolances to the dead and injured in what he called a terrorist attack.
This attack comes weeks before the Winter Olympics open in Sochi, about 650 kilometers south of Volgograd. Islamist militants have threatened to disrupt the Games.
An attack in Volgograd by a female suicide bomber on October 21 killed five people and wounded 30. Investigators also identified her as coming from Dagestan.
Dagestan is the epicenter of an ongoing Islamist insurgency in the North Caucasus.
In early July, the leader of the Islamist insurgency in the North Caucasus, Doku Umarov, declared an end to a moratorium on attacks on Russian civilian targets that he had announced the previous year.
UPDATE 8:00PM – We thought that a reference to a female bomber was removed by the Voice of America from a report on the VOA English website, but we found later that it is still there as of 8:00 PM ET with VOA English News failing to remove, correct and update disputed information or to include U.S. and international reactions to the terror attack in Russia.
“MOSCOW — Russian officials say they believe a female suicide bomber caused an explosion that killed at least 16 people and wounded dozens Sunday at the entrance to a train station in Volgograd.” — VOA English News as of 8:15PM ET. Suicide Bomber Kills 16 at Russian Train Station
All other international media outlets have been questioning this report for hours after Russian officials themselves had stated that they are no longer sure how many people were involved and who caused the explosion.
This is what DW (Deutsche Welle) is reporting:
“A bombing at a train station in the Russian city of Volgograd has killed more than a dozen people and injured many more. Questions remain over the gender of the attacker after initial reports said the bomber was female.” — DW (Deutsche Welle) Blast at Russia’s Volgograd train station leaves more than a dozen dead
This is what BBC English News is reporting:
“Initial official claims that the bomber was a lone woman have been replaced by uncertainty about who carried it out.” — BBC ‘Suicide bomber’ hits Russia’s Volgograd train station
This is what RT (Russia Today) is reporting:
“Suicide bomber’s identity disputed
The Committee originally said a female suicide bomber detonated the bomb when she saw a police officer while approaching the metal detector.
But since then the suicide bomber’s identity has been disputed. The female was initially identified as Oksana Aslanova, a close friend of Naida Asiyalova – also known as ‘Amaturahman’ – who was behind the October Volgograd attack. Aslanova is said to have been married twice to two militants, both eliminated earlier.
A few hours later, more evidence emerged suggesting that a man could have also been involved in the attack. The version, which was also picked up by investigators, came after a male finger with a pin from a grenade was found at the scene.
Given the new information, the possibility that the attack could have been carried out by both a man and a woman is not ruled out, Markin said.” — RT (Russia Today) Suicide bomber kills 16 in Russia’s Volgograd (VIDEO)
This is what Al Jazeera English is reporting:
“Vladimir Markin, the spokesman for the nation’s top investigative agency, the Investigative Committee, said the suicide bomber detonated her, the bomber was initially believed to be a women but officials later said this was not certain, explosives in front of a metal detector.” — Al Jazeera Deadly blast hits Russian train station
VOA English report on the terror bombing in Russia shows 136 Facebook Likes as of 8:15PM ET.
BBC English report on the terror bombing in Russia shows 3,795 Facebook Likes as of 8:15PM ET.
RT English report on the terror bombing in Russia shows over 2,600 Facebook Likes as of 8:15PM ET.
Al Jazeera report on the terror bombing in Russia shows 1,303 Facebook Likes as of 8:15PM ET.
DW does not show social media stats on its English website.
UPDATE 7:30PM ET – As of 7:30PM ET, a reference in the VOA English report from Moscow to “a female suicide bomber” has finally been removed hours after BBC and RT (Russia Today) have already posted information contradicting this initial report.
It took VOA English News many hours to remove and correct possibly inaccurate and in any case disputed information.
[We were wrong and somehow missed that VOA did not actually remove this disputed information. It was still in the report at 8PM ET.]
VOA English News is still not reporting on the State Department Statement of a statement of condolences from U.S. Ambassador Michael McFaul, which was posted online more than 10 hours ago. RT has been reporting on both statements for some hours.
UPDATE 7:00PM ET: It has been over 10 hours since U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul issued his statement of condolences after the suicide terror attack in Volgograd, in which 16 people are reported dead, but the Voice of America (VOA) English news website has still not reported on his statement or on a later statement from the U.S. State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki condemning the attack.
Other than changing the number of dead — but still hours later than BBC, Al Jazeera, RT (Russia Today), and RFE/RL’s Radio Liberty Russian Service (Radio Svoboda) — the VOA English website report has not been updated with any new additional information for over 7 hours.
VOA report still says: “MOSCOW — Russian officials say they believe a female suicide bomber caused an explosion that killed at least 16 people and wounded dozens Sunday at the entrance to a train station in Volgograd.”
BBC has already been reporting for some hours that “initial official claims that the bomber was a lone woman have been replaced by uncertainty about who carried it out.”
RT (Russia Today) has also been reporting for some hours that the person who set off the explosion has not been positively identified.
Suicide bomber’s identity disputed
The Committee originally said a female suicide bomber detonated the bomb when she saw a police officer while approaching the metal detector.
But since then the suicide bomber’s identity has been disputed. (…)
A few hours later, more evidence emerged suggesting that a man could have also been involved in the attack. The version, which was also picked up by investigators, came after a male finger with a pin from a grenade was found at the scene. – RT (Russia Today) Suicide bomber kills 16 in Russia’s Volgograd (VIDEO)
The VOA English website report is not being corrected and updated with any of the new information, which contradicts the VOA report and is being reported by BBC, RT, and RFE/RL’s Radio Liberty (Radio Svoboda) Russian Service.
Un-updated VOA English reports shows
There is also still nothing on the VOA English website on the State Department statement.
The State Department statement has now been posted online for about two to three hours.
It took five hours to correct a news report on the Voice of America (VOA) English website first showing only 14 dead as a result of the suicide terror attack in Russia while BBC, RT (Russia Today) RFE/RL and most other international media updated their reports hours ago that the number of dead had reached 16 according to official Russian sources.
VOA English News never reported on a statement of condolences posted online more than 8 hours ago by U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul. RT (Russia Today) quickly reported on the U.S. Ambassador’s statement.
RT also reported on the statement from the U.S. State Department condemning the attack.
Voice of America (VOA) English website is not reporting on these statements as of 6PM ET, Dec. 29.
The Voice of America English website is also not reporting on the State Department’s statement as of 6PM ET, Dec. 29. VOA English News has also not reported on Ambassador McFaul’s statement.
VOA English News also has not reported on any world reactions to the attack. RT (Russia Today) reports on statements from the UN and the European Union.
Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty (RFE/RL) Russian Service (Radio Svoboda) has provided continuous coverage with frequent updates, videos, photos, audio interviews and Twitter embeds.
Like VOA, RFE/RL is also overseen by the Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG).
While the VOA Russian Service has updated some of its reporting, it was also slow and late.
RFE/RL’s Radio Svoboda is providing outstanding live coverage.
As of 6PM ET, VOA English report only recently updated with the correct number of dead but without any U.S. or international reactions to the attack, shows 97 Facebook Likes.
As of 6PM ET, BBC English shows over 3,000 Facebook Likes.
The State Department Statement has been posted online for more than an hour.
STATE DEPARTMENT PRESS STATEMENT
Condemning Terrorist Bombing in Volgograd
Press Statement
Jen Psaki
Department Spokesperson
Washington, DC
December 29, 2013The United States condemns in the strongest terms today’s terrorist attack in Volgograd. We send our sincere condolences to the families of the victims and stand in solidarity with the Russian people against terrorism of any kind.
UPDATE 5:30 PM ET
VOA English News has revised its figure of dead from the attack from 14 to 16. This is the first update on the VOA English website in about five hours.
VOA English News is still not reporting on U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul’s statement of condolences posted more than 8 hours ago. VOA English News is also not reporting on the State Department statement. RT (Russia Today) has reported on both Ambassador McFaul’s statement and the statement from the State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki.
UPDATE 5:15 PM ET
Russia’s state-funed international media outlet RT (Russia Today) reported that Washington has strongly condemned the terror attack in Volgograd. State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki expressed condolences to the families of the victims and solidarity with the Russian people, RT reported. U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul also expressed condolences, RT reported a few hours ago. Ambassador McFaul posted his statement of condolences online more than 8 hours ago.
The Voice of America (VOA) English news website report on the terror attack in Russia has not been updated in nearly five hours and does not include any mention of the State Department statement of the much earlier statement of condolences from Ambassador McFaul.
The VOA Russian Service has reported with a few hour delay on Ambassador McFaul’s statement. It has now also reported on the State Department statement.
The vast majority of other VOA language services are not reporting on these U.S. statements and are still giving the wrong, lower number of dead, since the VOA English Newsroom has not been updating its report.
The VOA English News report shows only 14 dead. BBC, RT, RFE/RL Russian Service, and many other major international media outlets quote official Russian sources who reported some hours ago that the number of dead now stands at 16.
UPDATE: 5:00PM ET – A report on the VOA English website on the suicide terror attack in Volgograd (formerly Stalingrad), Russia, has not been updated with any new information for nearly five hours. The VOA Russian Service website report has been updated but with considerable delay (VOA Russian reports 16 dead, while VOA English reports 14 dead).
Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty (RFE/RL) Russian Service (Radio Svoboda) is providing outstanding continuous online coverage with numerous videos, photos, audio interviews, Twitter embeds and constant updates.
SEE: Теракт в Волгограде, RFE/RL Radio Liberty (Radio Svoboda) Russian Service.
VOA Russian Service report now shows 71 Facebook Likes.
RFE/RL Radio Svoboda Russian Service report now shows 587 Facebook Likes.
VOA English report, which has not been updated for nearly five hours, now shows 61 Facebook Likes
BBC English report now shows 3,164 Facebook Likes.
RT (Russia Today) English report, which includes U.S. Ambassador Michael McFaul’s statement of condolences, now shows over 2,400 Facebook Likes.
VOA English News is not reporting on U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul’s statement of condolences which has been posted on his Facebook and Twitter accounts for nearly 8 hours. VOA English News still reports 14 dead. BBC, RT (Russia Today), RFE/RL and most other major international media outlets have provided constant updates. They have all been reporting 16 dead quoting Russian officials for the last three of four hours.
UPDATE: 4:24PM ET – A report on the VOA English website on the suicide terror attack in Volgograd (formerly Stalingrad), Russia, has not been updated with any new information for more than four hours.
VOA English News is also not reporting on U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul’s statement of condolences which has been posted on his Facebook and Twitter accounts for more than 7 hours. VOA English News still reports 14 dead. BBC, RT (Russia Today), RFE/RL and most other major international media outlets have provided constant updates. They all report 16 dead quoting Russian officials.
Выражаем соболезнования родным и близким погибших и пострадавшим при теракте в Волгограде.
— Michael McFaul (@McFaul) December 29, 2013
Un-updated VOA English report now shows 36 Facebook Likes and 28 Tweets.
BBC English report now shows 3,094 Facebook Likes and 1,455 Tweets.
UPDATE 3:45 PM ET – VOA English News still has not updated its report on the suicide terror attack in Volgograd Russia. The report has not been updated now for close to four hours. VOA English News still reports 14 dead. All major international media report 16 dead.
Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty (RFE/RL) Radio Svoboda Russian Service provides excellent continuous coverage with live updates.
It has also been more than seven hours since U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul posted his statement of condolences on both his Facebook and Twitter account. VOA English News has not yet reported on it or on any other reactions being reported now for many hours already by BBC, RT (Russia Today) and other international and U.S. media.
UPDATE: 3 PM ET – We missed it earlier, but RT (Russia Today) reported at 11:20 AM ET on U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul’s statement of condolences 14:20 GMT: The US Ambassador to Russia, Michael McFaul, has given his condolences to the relatives of the slain and injured in the Volgograd blast. The statement was published on his Twitter account.
The VOA English News website has still not updated its report, now for at least three hours. The headline still reads 14 dead. It is astounding that RT, Russia’s state media outlet, would report on Ambassador McFaul’s statement and VOA English News would not. The VOA Russian Service did mention the U.S. Ambassador’s statement but with a considerable delay. BBG Watch may have been the first media outlet to report it.
Ambassador McFaul’s statement has been now online for more than 7 hours.
UPDATE: 2:45 PM ET Al Jazeera reports at least 15 dead. VOA English News still reports 14 dead and is not updating its report. BBC, RFE/RL Russian Service, RT (Russia Today) report at least 16 dead.
Al Jazeera English report (Middle East website) now shows 1,202 Facebook Likes and 222 Tweets.
Still un-updated VOA English report now shows 26 Facebook Likes and 24 Tweets.
BBC report now shows 2,642 Facebook Likes and 1,408 Tweets.
One of the two RT (Russia Today) reports, Suicide bomber kills 16 in Russia’s Volgograd (VIDEO), RT now shows over 2,200 Facebook Likes and 1,185 Tweets.
The second RT report, Volgograd railway station blast: LIVE UPDATES, RT, now shows 981 Facebook Likes and 737 Tweets.
UPDATE: 2:35 PM ET – RT (Russia Today) reported: 19:16 GMT: UN Security Council has condemned the Volgograd bombing “in the strongest terms” and registered its condolences for the victims and their families, the body’s official statement reads.
VOA English website still has not updated its report for about three hours. The VOA English headline still refers to 14 dead. VOA English News is not reporting on any U.S. or international reactions to the suicide terror attack. Statements from U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul, the European Council, and the UN are not reported on the VOA English website.
UPDATE: 2:25 PM ET – RFE/RL Radio Liberty’s Russian Service (Radio Svoboda) is constantly updating its report with new information, new interviews, videos, Tweets and other material.
Radio Svoboda reports at least 16 dead, as does BBC, RT, and many other international media. VOA English News still reports 14 dead. VOA Russian Service reports 15 dead.
RFE/RL’s Russian Service continuing coverage now has seven audio reports, including an interview with the mayor of Volgograd, three videos, and a number of embedded Tweets from eyewitnesses and commentators.
SEE: Теракт в Волгограде, RFE/RL Radio Svoboda (Radio Liberty) Russian Service.
Radio Svoboda report now shows 499 Facebook Likes and 37 Tweets.
UPDATE: 2:14 PM ET – VOA English News not updating its report for more than two hours. VOA headline still says 14 dead. BBC, RT (Russia Today) report at least 16 dead. VOA English News still not reporting on U.S. Ambassador Michael McFaul’s statement.
VOA English report now shows 22 Facebook Likes and 22 Tweets.
BBC report shows 2,536 Facebook Likes and 1,389 Tweets.
VOA Russian report, which is slightly more updated than VOA English report, now shows 55 Facebook Likes and 10 Tweets.
RT reports: 16:19 GMT: The European Council has condemned “in the strongest terms the heinous” terror attack in Volgograd. The Council’s president, Herman Van Rompuy, has expressed “heartfelt condolences” to the families of the victims and “solidarity to the Government and people of Russia.”
Statement on heinous terrorist attack in #Volgograd
http://t.co/DKCPkp8UIj
— Herman Van Rompuy (@euHvR) December 29, 2013
UPDATE: 2 PM ET – VOA English News is still not updating its report from Moscow. The headline reports 14 dead; the report says at least 14 dead. It should not be assumed that a VOA reporter in Moscow has not provided an update to the VOA Central English Newsroom in Washington, but because of general mismanagement, updates from VOA correspondents are often hours late being posted on the VOA English website.
BBC reports: “A suicide attack on a train station in Russia’s southern city of Volgograd has killed 16 people, officials say.”
VOA English reports now shows 18 Facebook Likes and 17 Tweets. BBC, RT (Russia Today) now show thousands of Facebook Likes and Tweets.
UPDATE – 1:40 PM ET – VOA English News is still not reporting on U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul’s statement of condolences posted on his Facebook and Twitter accounts more than 4 hours ago. VOA Russian Service reported on it about three hours after it was posted.
Выражаем соболезнования родным и близким погибших и пострадавшим при теракте в Волгограде.
— Michael McFaul (@McFaul) December 29, 2013
UPDATE – 1:30 PM ET: VOA English still reports 14 dead. VOA Russian now reports 15 dead. VOA English News added a small map to its report, but it is not otherwise updating.
One of the RT reports shows over 2,000 Facebook Likes and 1,161 Tweets.
UPDATE: As of 12:50 PM ET, BBC and other media report 16 dead after the suicide terror attack in Volgograd, while VOA English News still reports 14 dead. Some media report 15 dead. VOA English website added video but did not otherwise update its report.
BBC report shows 2,227 Facebook Likes and over 1,000 Tweets.
VOA English News report shows 11 Facebook Likes and 0 (zero) Tweets.
RFE/RL English report shows 42 Facebook Likes and 38 Tweets.
RFE/RL Russian report shows 434 Facebook Likes and 35 Tweets.
VOA Russian report shows 39 Facebook Likes and 10 Tweets.
VOA Russian Service still shows 14 dead. The website now includes video and some additional text.
Like BBC and RFE/RL, RT (Russia Today) is constantly updating its reports on the Volgograd suicide terror attack. Quoting an official source, RT is also reporting at least 16 dead. VOA English and VOA Russian still show 14 dead.
“According to verified information, the explosion at the railway station in Volgograd has claimed 16 lives,” Russia’s Investigative Committee said. — RT (Russia Today)
VOA Russian is now reporting on Ambassador McFaul’s statement of condolences. VOA English News is still not reporting on the statement.